Bossy Librarian
  • Home
  • Blog
  • AUTHORS
  • About

Before we were yours by lisa Wingate

11/26/2019

22 Comments

 

No Spoiler Book Review

Picture
This was my second community book club read. The first book we read, Marriage Lie, was a best-selling mystery that I did not personally care for, but the group loved. This was a best-selling historical fiction that I did not personally care for, but the group loved. Hopefully, this does not become a trend, because I really like this group!

If I had edited this book, it would have been very different. The author had such an intriguing premise, human trafficking of children during the great depression. That is an interesting story, based on true events. I liked the parts of the book that were actually historical. Anything having to do with the Foss family children was great. What I didn’t like was the modern narrative of pampered granddaughter, Avery, it added nothing to the story. I literally would have ripped all the “Avery” chapters out of this book if I was the editor.

That being said, I will still rate this book three stars on Goodreads. While half of this book put me to sleep every time that I read it (I’m looking at you Avery), the other half was not only interesting, but important as well. This would be a great choice for most book clubs, human trafficking is a problem that merits more than just a discussion, but discussion is a start.  

Check back on Thursday for a Happy Thanksgiving Post!

Share your thoughts on this book. Comment below:

    Stay Connected!

Subscribe to Newsletter
22 Comments
Kathryn Oleary link
11/27/2019 06:22:51 am

This sounds like an intriguing storyline: I’m with you on the dual narrative though, I often think that this style interrupts the story and characterisation.

Reply
Alison Kelly
11/27/2019 12:32:06 pm

If it’s done well, it’s so good. Unfortunately, I don’t think most authors can pull it off...

Reply
Alice Rusalka link
11/30/2019 07:06:28 am

I hope the trend does not continue with the next book too! I also agree with the assessment that this is an important topic for discussion. If you are interested I might suggest "The Road of Lost Innocence: the True story of a Combodian Heroine." It is an overall inspiring book.

Reply
Alison Kelly
11/30/2019 10:56:49 am

Well, the trend did not exactly continue, but it didn’t get better either. Didn’t like the latest book, but neither did anyone else.... I generally don’t finish books I don’t like, so I’m going to apply that to book club as well.

Reply
Amie Cadwallader
11/30/2019 10:31:13 am

This sounds so intriguing, I'm adding to my to purchase list!

Love, Amie ❤
<a href="http://thecurvaceousvegan.com">The Curvaceous Vegan</a>

Reply
Alison Kelly
11/30/2019 11:08:55 am

It does have an interesting premise and most of the ladies in book club really loved it! Let me know what you think!

Reply
Angie link
11/30/2019 10:35:12 am

This book does sound kind of interesting.

Although I can really relate to the issue you're having with your book club picks - I always feel like I like the choices less than the rest of my group. I eventually just accepted my role as the group's resident nay-sayer! And then I moved away, so now I just read whatever I want. Lol.

Reply
Alison Kelly
11/30/2019 11:00:15 am

Pretty much! I decided, I’m not going to keep reading the books I don’t like, I’ll just skip them.

Reply
Fadima Mooneira link
12/1/2019 07:27:52 am

This book sounds interesting and informative to read. Your review makes me interested to read it. Tq for sharing.

Reply
Alison Kelly
12/1/2019 10:41:37 am

It is a really well rated book, if the story sounds interesting to you, you should check it out!

Reply
Serena Cooper link
12/1/2019 08:49:41 am

This book was so heartbreaking - and I like your blog name - I’m The Bossy Brunette 😉

Reply
Alison Kelly
12/1/2019 11:20:36 am

I’m so glad you enjoyed it. It is such an important topic and I am glad that this author has helped bring more people into the conversation!

Reply
Lisa Marie Alioto link
12/1/2019 12:21:29 pm

I'm not sure I would be a fan of historical fiction. I'm with you! I hope the group turns to some new genres for you.

Reply
Alison Kelly
12/2/2019 01:15:57 pm

I actually really love Historical Fiction. Try Kristin Hannah, if you are looking for a good author. It looks like we are doing kind of a spooky mystery for our next read, which is more up my alley! Thanks for saying Hi!

Reply
Jaya Avendel link
12/1/2019 01:15:52 pm

Definitely and important topic for discussion, so it is a pity the author did not put more care into so that the chapters keep one awake rather then playing down the horror of human trafficking and making one doze off.

Thank you for sharing your thoughts! I always love honest reviews.

Reply
Alison Kelly
12/2/2019 01:25:51 pm

All my reviews are honest, and usually positive, since I only finish books I actually like. This snuck by in Book Club...

Reply
Carolyn link
12/2/2019 06:54:15 am

Great post! I had no idea human trafficking was a problem during the Great Depression. I may recommend this to my bookclub for January (though may recommend we skip all of the Avery parts). Thanks!

Reply
Alison Kelly
12/2/2019 01:27:20 pm

Everyone else seemed to enjoy this book. Please let me know if you would like suggestions for what to read in book club.

Reply
Je link
12/2/2019 06:55:01 am

Now I'm curious what happened with Avery. :)

I love historical fiction. Stories from the past are a great insight into how much we have changed. Or not changed.

Reply
Alison Kelly
12/2/2019 01:29:12 pm

Let me know if you decide to read it! I'd love to hear your opinion of Avery!

Reply
Amy link
12/2/2019 08:48:04 am

I haven't read this book, or actually heard of it before, but it sounds like something I'd pick up. My mum really likes historical fiction though so it might just be a Christmas present idea for her :)

Reply
Alison Kelly
12/2/2019 01:30:48 pm

Please let me know if you would like some Christmas gift ideas!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Alison Kelly

    Archives

    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019

    Categories

    All
    Book Lists
    Book Reviews
    Interviews
    Library Life

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Blog
  • AUTHORS
  • About